Skip to main content
Ad (425x293)

Burnham to argue Brexit cost UK more than it delivered ahead of EU summit

Prime Minister Andy Burnham will argue at the Lord Mayor's Banquet that Brexit has cost the UK more than it has gained, ahead of a UK-EU summit on 20 November where new agreements on food, energy and youth mobility are expected to be finalised.

By The UK Pulse Editorial Team·Source: BBC News··6 min read·How we work
Andy Burnham touches his chin as he sits in front of the UK and EU flags while attending a business summit at the Chancellery in Berlin in October.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham is expected to deliver a stark assessment of Britain's post-Brexit position during a speech at the Lord Mayor's Banquet on Monday, contending that the country has forfeited more economically and strategically than it has gained from leaving the European Union. According to BBC News, Burnham will use the occasion to set out his vision for resetting the UK-EU relationship ahead of a summit scheduled for 20 November 2026 in Brussels.

In his remarks, Burnham will invoke the fable of the emperor's new clothes to describe what he characterises as a flawed Brexit settlement. He intends to argue that the departure from the EU created unnecessary obstacles for businesses while failing to deliver on the central promise of reclaiming sovereignty.

"It's like the emperor's new clothes – where no-one is prepared to say the obvious truth. Well, I say it as I see it. And to be frank, the emperor has nothing on. The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we have gained."

The government's approach differs from outright criticism of the Brexit decision itself. Rather, Burnham frames his position as a critique of how the departure was executed, arguing that a more constructive engagement with Brussels can remedy the shortcomings of the original settlement negotiated by his predecessor Sir Keir Starmer in May 2025.

At Friday's summit, Burnham is scheduled to formalise new agreements covering food, energy and youth mobility with the EU bloc. The substance of these arrangements was largely determined during Starmer's tenure, with negotiations now in their final stages. Burnham has previously claimed these deals could add £10 billion annually to the UK economy by 2040, addressing trade barriers that have constrained business activity since 2020.

The food and agriculture agreement represents a particularly significant development. A draft UK-EU food deal has been agreed that would remove post-Brexit export checks and align relevant standards dynamically, with the government estimating the arrangement could eventually deliver £5.1 billion in annual economic benefits. The accord is also reported to restore pet passports, allowing repeated EU trips without requiring a new health certificate for each journey. Negotiations on the youth scheme have involved a UK proposal for 75,000–80,000 places, while the EU has sought 100,000 positions.

What tests will Burnham apply to any agreement?

Burnham has established three criteria against which any new arrangement must be measured. The first requires consistency with Labour's 2024 general election manifesto, which explicitly ruled out a return to the single market, the customs union, or freedom of movement. This red line reflects the government's determination to maintain the outcome of the 2016 referendum while improving the practical terms of Britain's relationship with the bloc.

The second test, which Burnham terms the "Makerfield test", demands that any agreement deliver tangible improvements to people's everyday lives. This standard reflects his emphasis on demonstrating concrete benefits to voters rather than pursuing abstract institutional arrangements. The third criterion requires that any deal represent a genuine improvement on the original Brexit settlement and move closer to what voters believed they were endorsing in 2016.

Ad (425x293)

Burnham characterises the prospect of a revised arrangement as a "win-win" outcome that exemplifies a fundamentally different approach to EU relations.

"Not adversarial. No longer burning bridges. But being constructive and positive - showing that we can come together to confront shared challenges."

What are the Conservative and opposition responses?

The Conservative Party has mounted a sharp critique of the government's strategy, accusing Labour of attempting to reverse Brexit through incremental steps.

"Dragging us into the European Union via the back door with their EU reset"
is how the party has characterised the approach. Boris Johnson, who served as prime minister when the UK formally departed the EU in 2020 and negotiated the original Brexit agreement, has issued a direct warning to Burnham. In comments to the Daily Telegraph, Johnson argued that pursuing EU relations as a political priority would prove self-defeating, contending that the public would endorse Brexit again if given another vote.

Deputy Conservative leader Alex Burghart has accused Burnham of "reopening a debate the country settled long ago, while ignoring the challenges facing Britain today". Reform UK has emphasised that a key advantage of Brexit is freedom from EU regulatory requirements, warning that any form of alignment could constrain Britain's independent trade policy. The Liberal Democrats, by contrast, have dismissed the food export agreement as merely a "patch, not a fix", arguing that the genuine solution lies in rejoining the single market and establishing a customs union. The Green Party of England and Wales has called for full customs union membership, with party leader Zack Polanski previously stating that "full membership of the EU remains the best option for the UK".

What is Burnham's position on longer-term options?

Burnham has indicated a willingness to examine the "pros and cons" of different models for Britain's future relationship with the EU, a stance that signals that rejoining could be among options the government examines to reshape the UK's long-term relationship with the bloc. Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband has told the BBC that the prime minister will lay out these potential options following the UK-EU summit. However, Burnham has explicitly ruled out implementing major changes before the next general election, emphasising that any fundamental shift in Britain's EU relationship would require a fresh electoral mandate from voters.

Burnham has rejected claims of inconsistency over his EU position, insisting his government maintains a unified approach ahead of the November summit in Brussels, while reaffirming that manifesto red lines on freedom of movement remain non-negotiable.

What background led to this moment?

The current negotiations build on commitments made during the May 2025 UK-EU summit, which established a framework for working toward a youth experience scheme, a common food and animal-product standards area, and linking emissions trading schemes. The November summit was originally scheduled for July 2026 but was postponed following Keir Starmer's resignation as prime minister.

What happens next?

The UK-EU summit is scheduled for 20 November 2026 in Brussels, where the two sides are expected to announce formal agreements on food, emissions trading and youth mobility. These arrangements represent the culmination of months of technical negotiation and represent the government's attempt to demonstrate that a more collaborative approach to EU relations can deliver practical benefits to British businesses and citizens.

Ad (425x293)

Related News