Skip to main content
Ad (425x293)

Fernandez Benched as Anderson Shines in City's Fulham Stalemate

Manchester City drew 1-1 with Fulham as Elliot Anderson's second-half volley rescued a point, extending their winless streak to four matches. Manager Enzo Maresca's decision to bench record signing Enzo Fernandez in favour of Ayyoub Bouaddi raised questions about how to integrate the club's £327m

By The UK Pulse Editorial Team·Source: BBC Sport··6 min read·How we work
Elliot Anderson and Ayyoub Bouaddi

Manchester City manager Enzo Maresca made a bold tactical decision by dropping club record signing Enzo Fernandez to the bench for the match against Fulham, instead deploying Ayyoub Bouaddi alongside Elliot Anderson in midfield. The decision proved partially vindicated when Anderson scored a stunning second-half volley to rescue a 1-1 draw, though the result extended City's winless run to four Premier League matches and drew audible frustration from home supporters at the Etihad Stadium.

According to BBC Sport, Maresca explained his team selection by stating he believed Bouaddi's presence would provide better balance. "I just think for this game it's better having Ayyoub Bouaddi in there," he told TNT Sports before kick-off. The Italian manager had acknowledged on Friday that he was searching for "more balance" across his defensive line, midfield and attacking areas following three consecutive Premier League defeats.

Fernandez's absence may have been influenced by his lengthy trip back to Argentina during the international break for friendlies against Uruguay and Costa Rica, which included a visit to his boyhood club River Plate. However, Maresca did not publicly cite this as his reasoning. The £125m club record acquisition was eventually introduced for the final five minutes, replacing Bouaddi.

How did Anderson perform in his expanded role?

Anderson delivered an impressive display when given licence to roam forward alongside Bouaddi, a tactical arrangement that contrasted sharply with his usual role when Fernandez plays. The England international created a match-high three chances and maintained a 100% success rate from 16 passes in the final third. He recorded seven touches in the opposition box, contested more duels than any other player with 17 challenges, and won possession back more times than any teammate.

His standout moment came when he unleashed a spectacular volley to level the score after City had fallen behind to Rodrigo Muniz's superb curling effort in the first half. According to The Analyst, Anderson's strike was his first Premier League goal for City, and notably four of his six Premier League goals excluding penalties have come from outside the box.

Maresca praised both midfielders after the match.

Ayyoub with Elliot were both really good. Today we used Elliot a bit more attacking midfielder, he arrived inside the box and scored a fantastic goal, he had three or four moments around the box where he was really dangerous. It is another solution for us. In this moment, we are trying to know each other more as players and also to find the right solution.

Did Cherki's arrival restrict Anderson?

Anderson's influence diminished significantly after Rayan Cherki was introduced as a substitute for Phil Foden. The substitution forced Anderson to retreat into a deeper midfield role, limiting his ability to make attacking runs into the box. Former City goalkeeper Joe Hart, speaking to BBC Sport, observed that

Elliot Anderson was going to take the game by the scruff of the neck but then Cherki came on and took his position. So he didn't have as much of an impact on the game.

Hart acknowledged the tactical reasoning behind the change.

I understood the change - when the lines are deep, there were chances of Cherki unlocking Fulham, but they just defended so well and they also offered a threat on the break.
Maresca's substitution reflected his attempt to inject fresh attacking impetus, though it ultimately proved unsuccessful in breaking down Fulham's defensive resolve.

Ad (425x293)

Where does Fernandez fit in City's system?

The absence of Fernandez raises fundamental questions about how to integrate City's summer midfield overhaul. The club invested £327m across three signings: Fernandez at £125m, along with Anderson and Bouaddi. Maresca noted in his pre-match news conference that City had "won games with Enzo and lost games with Enzo," suggesting inconsistency in the midfielder's performances.

The number 10 position, traditionally occupied by either Cherki or Foden, appears to be where Fernandez's future role lies. Yet Bouaddi's defensive solidity allows Anderson to play his natural attacking game, creating a tactical puzzle for Maresca. Hart reflected on the challenge of managing such an expensive squad.

There is no point in having a brilliant squad like Manchester City if you are not going to take that into account. It's very much understandable, if you're going to have a squad and you trust everyone - if someone's done the travelling, he has done the game time, you have got to expect to not use him as much.

The manager must determine how to deploy all three midfielders effectively, particularly given the investment required and the expectations surrounding Fernandez's club record transfer fee.

What was the broader context of the match?

City displayed a flat first-half performance, falling behind to Muniz's well-executed finish. A nervous tension permeated the Etihad from the opening whistle, seemingly affecting the players on the pitch. The draw represented a disappointing result given City's desperate need for victory after three consecutive defeats.

Notably, according to Times Union, the result ended Manchester City's 20-match winning streak against Fulham in all competitions, a run dating back to 2012. Additionally, Erling Haaland had a first-half equaliser ruled out after officials judged he had fouled goalkeeper Bernd Leno by kicking the ball from his hands.

The draw extended City's winless run and left supporters audibly frustrated at full-time. Maresca acknowledged the difficulty of the situation.

For sure we don't like these kind of moments in terms of four games in a row without a win. We also know that, unfortunately, it is normal or part of the path, you go through these kind of moments. It is important that we find a way to keep clean sheets that sometimes you need to win games 1-0 for a small difference.

What lies ahead for City?

Manchester City face a crucial period with Champions League action against Napoli on Tuesday followed by a significant trip to Arsenal the following Sunday. City could head to the Emirates eight points behind the defending champions if results do not improve. According to BBC Sport, the draw against Fulham was the first match in a run of seven Premier League games that will test City's ability to recover from their current form.

Maresca will need to find solutions to balance his midfield options while maintaining defensive stability. The manager's tactical flexibility, demonstrated against Fulham, suggests he remains willing to experiment with different combinations as City attempt to arrest their poor run of results.

Ad (425x293)

Related News