Skip to main content
Ad (425x293)

Google refuses UK request to remove Russell Brand's prison innocence claim video

Google has rejected a UK government request to remove a YouTube video in which jailed comedian Russell Brand claims his innocence. The Prison Service submitted the removal request, arguing the content distressed victims, but Google said its standards had not been breached.

By The UK Pulse Editorial Team·Source: BBC News··6 min read·How we work
Russell Brand and his wife Laura are shown outside of court, standing beside a car with their arms around each other.

Google has declined a government request to take down a YouTube video in which jailed comedian Russell Brand, through his wife Laura, asserts his innocence following his conviction for rape and sexual assault, according to BBC News. The Prison Service of England and Wales formally submitted the removal request, arguing the content was distressing to Brand's victims. Google responded that its community standards had not been violated and declined to remove the material.

Brand is currently serving a 10-and-a-half-year sentence after being convicted of rape and three counts of sexual assault. On Sunday, his wife shared a video on their YouTube channel in which Brand stated:

I am not guilty of the offences I have been jailed for.
The video was distributed to the couple's 6.6 million YouTube rs.

A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said it was appropriate to request removal of material deemed

distressing for victims
and maintained that
YouTube should remove this content
. However, the department acknowledged that
removal ultimately depends on the platform's own terms
.

How did the government make its request?

The Prison Service submitted the request through an established mechanism it uses with technology companies to seek deletion of material. Initial reports suggested a minister had met with Google directly, but the Ministry of Justice later clarified that the request was made via this formal channel rather than through a high-level meeting. Google told BBC News it was

aware of the new content and our teams are investigating
and noted that it had
suspended Russell Brand's channel from the YouTube Partner Program in September 2023. The channel has not been able to monetise on YouTube since then.

What are government officials saying?

Housing minister Matthew Pennycook described the video as

abhorrent
and said the government remained in
close dialogue
with Google. However, he acknowledged the government had no power to mandate removal of content, with such decisions depending on the platform's terms and conditions.

Jess Phillips, the former minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that the government

doesn't have the power to enforce that this video is taken down
. She emphasised that
It relies on YouTube, in this instance ... to do the right thing, which is a much, much broader argument about whether Ofcom codes that are in the Online Safety Act are there actually to protect women.

Education Secretary Lucy Powell criticised media outlets for broadcasting extracts from Brand's message, saying they should not have

amplified
his words. She characterised Brand as
someone who's not showing a jot of remorse, a jot of any sensitivity at all to their victims
.

Children's minister Josh MacAlister pointed to Meta's approach as a template, noting that

Meta's community standards prohibit accounts owned by or run on behalf of convicted sex offenders, and it's as simple as that. Google should take this down.
Meta has already disabled Brand's accounts on Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp.

What does the regulatory framework say?

An Ofcom spokesperson stated that while current guidance

pushes platforms to go above and beyond their legal duties... ultimately parliament chose to make it voluntary
. The spokesperson added that
Any changes to the legislation to make it mandatory would be a matter for government and parliament.

Ad (425x293)

Phillips suggested it was

very likely
that the government would examine introducing a second online safety act to address gaps in the current regulatory framework. She noted that
Before, we haven't had prisoners who had massive YouTube followings. This is an entirely new era.

Is Brand being investigated for breaking prison rules?

Downing Street described Brand's message as

clearly appalling
and stated that
Prisoners are strictly banned from making statements that cause distress to victims, and speaking to the media is only permitted in exceptional circumstances.
The message has prompted an investigation into whether Brand breached prison regulations.

Justice Secretary Alex Norris said the case was being

urgently investigated, and I expect action to be taken if he is found to have broken the rules
. If Brand is found to have violated prison rules, potential consequences could include a temporary phone ban or live monitoring of his calls. In 2022, notorious inmate Charles Bronson reportedly had restrictions placed on his phone use after sending Sky News an unauthorised audio message about his parole bid.

Prisoners' phone conversations are routinely recorded, though not necessarily monitored by prison authorities in real time.

How have victims responded?

Mia Latter, a woman who has made allegations against Brand, described the video as

upsetting
and expressed dismay at hearing
this Christian message alongside absolute lies
. Latter, 37, has alleged she was raped by the comedian when she was 16. She was not a complainant in his recent criminal trial, and Brand denies her claims.

Speaking to BBC Radio 4's Today programme, Latter said:

I just felt for those women that stood trial and everything they went through.
She is one of several women who made allegations against Brand in 2023 as part of an investigation by the Times, Sunday Times and Channel 4's Dispatches programme.

What is Brand's current online presence?

The video and the Brands' YouTube account remain available on the platform as of 19 November. Brand's X account is also still active, with a message last appearing on 11 November that read:

There was never a Russell Brand, according to @meta. Thank God for @elonmusk. Stay tuned.
The message referenced Meta's decision to disable Brand's social media accounts and praised X's owner Elon Musk, who has publicly criticised Brand's conviction for historical sexual offences.

In recent years, Brand has positioned himself as a Christian influencer and has maintained a substantial online following across multiple platforms.

What happens next?

The Ministry of Justice is investigating whether Brand breached prison rules by sending the message through his wife's video. The outcome of this investigation could result in disciplinary action within the prison system. Additionally, government officials including Phillips have indicated that the government may pursue legislative changes to strengthen its ability to compel technology platforms to remove content involving convicted offenders, potentially through amendments to the Online Safety Act or new legislation.

Thin, red banner promoting the Politics Essential newsletter with text saying, “Top political analysis in your inbox every day”. There is also an image of the Houses of Parliament.

The case has highlighted tensions between platform autonomy and government authority in regulating content involving convicted criminals, with officials calling for clearer standards and potentially stronger legal mechanisms to address similar situations in the future.

Ad (425x293)

Related News