Amanda Mathewson, a 55-year-old childminder from Dunfermline, has pleaded guilty to wilfully neglecting and abandoning more than 20 children she was responsible for at her home. The case, heard at Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court, revealed that Mathewson had been caring for 27 children simultaneously—19 more than she was licensed to supervise. According to reporting on the case, the neglect spanned 50 weeks, from September 2023 to August 2024. Sheriff John MacRitchie deferred sentencing until 6 November to allow background reports to be prepared.
Mathewson, who had operated as a self-employed childminder for 30 years, admitted to leaving children alone and unsupervised on multiple occasions at various locations across Dunfermline and Fife. At the time of her arrest, she had 15 children aged under 12, 10 children below primary school age, and two infants under one year old in her care. Parents whose children were affected have described Mathewson as a "master manipulator" who concealed her actions through deception and carefully managed access to her home.
How was the neglect discovered?
Two parents became concerned after learning their children were not present during a school run that Mathewson was supposed to conduct. They visited the school to investigate and discovered their children were not with the childminder, despite having been left in her care. When they went to Mathewson's home, they heard a child screaming and found five unattended children in the garden with no adult supervision.
One of the children told the witnesses that no adults were inside the house and that Mathewson had instructed them to remain in the garden. Upon entering the unlocked property, the witnesses discovered a child crying beneath the kitchen table. An additional nine children, all under five years old, were located in an upstairs bedroom, with two of them strapped into prams. Although the children were described as distressed, none were physically injured. Police attended the scene, and Mathewson stated that the children had been left unattended for at least 30 minutes. Ring doorbell footage presented to the court demonstrated this was the second occasion that day when children had been left inside the house unsupervised.

What signs of neglect did parents notice?
Parents reported several concerning patterns that they did not fully recognise as warning signs at the time. Some parents noticed their children had not eaten while in Mathewson's care, evidenced by their clothes remaining in "pristine condition". A general theme emerged that children would return home thirsty. Other parents reported their children came home in dirty nappies or with dry faeces in their underwear.
Court documents revealed that Mathewson played loud music continuously and did not allow parents to enter her home at drop-off time, a practice designed to "conceal how oversubscribed she was". When parents raised concerns and asked questions, Mathewson consistently reassured them with "plausible explanations" that pre-empted their worries. One parent told investigators: "This was sustained, deliberate deception that concealed neglect from families and professionals alike. If she could build and manipulate the trust of adults across an entire community so effectively, think about how little power babies and young children had behind those closed doors."
How was she perceived in the community?
Before her crimes came to light, Mathewson was regarded as one of the best childminders in the area and was "loved and trusted" throughout the community. One parent described her as "a good friend". Her reputation for being friendly, caring and trustworthy with adults outside her home was instrumental in concealing what was happening to the children in her care.
The discovery of her actions has been devastating for families. One parent said: "We have had to rewrite eight years of history and have lost happy memories because the belief we had, that our children were being cared for, was not true." Another parent reflected on the emotional toll: "I cannot tell you what the first few months were like after all of this came to light. Every single parent involved has gone over in their head every conversation and any comment their child ever made—anything at the time seemed innocent enough but in hindsight could have been a red flag."
What were the licensing requirements?
According to the Care Inspectorate's registration conditions, Mathewson was permitted to provide childcare for a maximum of eight children at any one time. The regulations specified that no more than six could be under 12 years old, no more than three could have started primary school, and only one could be under 12 months old. By having 27 children in her home, she was operating at more than three times her licensed capacity.
An unannounced inspection conducted approximately one year before her arrest had rated the service highly. The Care Inspectorate's August 2023 report assigned ratings of "very good"—the second-highest level on the quality scale—to areas including care, learning, and the setting. The report stated that
children were cared for in a comfortable, welcoming and homely environmentand
were cared for with warmth, kindness and a nurturing approach. The inspection found no upheld complaints since the previous assessment. According to local reporting, the final glowing inspection took place in August 2023, approximately one month before the offending began.
What action did regulators take?
Following the allegations, the Care Inspectorate cancelled Mathewson's childminding registration while the investigation proceeded. In November 2024, Fife Council confirmed it would provide assistance to police and other authorities conducting the inquiry. Police Scotland charged Mathewson under Section 12 of the Children and Young Persons (Scotland) Act, which addresses cruelty and neglect of children.
Procurator fiscal Vicki Bell presented evidence to the court detailing how Mathewson had offered childcare places to more children than she could reasonably supervise at any given time. The court heard that she admitted to wilfully neglecting, abandoning, and exposing children to circumstances likely to cause them unnecessary suffering or injury to their health. The investigation found discrepancies in the number of children in Mathewson's care and the number of children she was seen with on multiple occasions.
A Care Inspectorate spokesperson described the case as "distressing" and stated that the organisation had implemented changes as a result of what occurred.
What happens next?
Sentencing has been deferred until 6 November 2026 pending the preparation of background reports. Mathewson's bail has been continued.
Key Facts
- Mathewson had 27 children in her home, compared to a licensed maximum of eight
- The neglect spanned 50 weeks, from September 2023 to August 2024
- Children were left unsupervised for at least 30 minutes, with ring doorbell footage showing this occurred twice in one day
- The Care Inspectorate had rated her service "very good" in August 2023, approximately one month before the offending began
- Her registration was cancelled following the allegations
- Sentencing is scheduled for 6 November 2026




