Skip to main content
Advertisement

Ministers Back Burnham Amid Labour MPs' Division Over Leadership Contest

Labour ministers back Andy Burnham as leadership frontrunner amid debate over a contest. Some MPs call for a democratic vote, while others urge swift transition to focus on governing.

·5 min read
Nick Thomas-Symonds

Ministers Endorse Burnham as Labour Leadership Controversy Continues

Nick Thomas-Symonds, a close ally of the Prime Minister and Cabinet Office minister, has publicly declared his support for Andy Burnham to succeed Sir Keir Starmer as Labour leader and prime minister.

Thomas-Symonds was among approximately 200 Labour MPs who posed with Burnham following his swearing-in as an MP on Monday.

Environment Secretary Emma Reynolds has also voiced strong support for Burnham, stating she doubts any rivals possess sufficient backing to mount a credible challenge.

Since Sir Keir announced his resignation, Labour MPs have been debating whether to hold a leadership contest or to allow Burnham, the apparent frontrunner, an uncontested path to Downing Street.

Andy Burnham took a selfie ahead of his swearing in ceremony, with about 200 of his Labour MP supporters

Andy Burnham is in the foreground, with a sea of Labour MPs behind him, including Nick Thomas-Symonds
Image caption, Andy Burnham took a selfie ahead of his swearing in ceremony, with about 200 of his Labour MP supporters

Former defence minister Al Carns and senior minister Darren Jones are reportedly considering entering the race, following the withdrawal of former health secretary Wes Streeting.

Speaking on BBC Breakfast, Thomas-Symonds explained his endorsement of Burnham by emphasizing the need for "someone with a track record of delivery and delivering change and that's what we've seen from Andy as Mayor of Greater Manchester."

"But secondly somebody who is best placed to defeat Reform at the next general election."

He highlighted Burnham's victory over Reform by more than 9,000 votes in Makerfield and added,

"My judgement is simply that we do need to be facing outward to the country and a swift and orderly transition is what I'll be supporting."

Some MPs, including Nottingham East's Nadia Whittome, advocate for a leadership contest during the summer as the only democratic method for Labour to evaluate candidates' policies.

However, many MPs loyal to Sir Keir remain skeptical about opposing Burnham, making it unlikely that Jones or Carns will secure the 81 nominations required to enter the contest.

An associate of Jones downplayed the chances of his candidacy, suggesting Jones is primarily seeking clarity on Burnham's economic policies.

Advertisement

Labour MPs Weigh Leadership Contest Versus Unopposed Transition

Chris Mason has noted increasing questions surrounding the likely successor to Starmer.

North Durham MP Luke Akehurst outlined the contest process on BBC Radio 4's World At One programme but indicated a contest might not be necessary.

"I shouldn't express a view on that because I'm a member of the NEC [National Executive Committee] but I think it would be a realistic assessment of where colleagues are in the PLP [Parliamentary Labour Party],"
"I think there's such a head of steam behind Andy Burnham that I suspect there won't be much of a contest and he may well get it at the nomination stage [16th July]."

Whittome, a member of Labour's Socialist Campaign Group, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that a contest would enable the party to address national challenges, including the cost of living crisis.

"We can't answer that question without candidates setting out their stall transparently, and being scrutinised by members and by unions,"
"I also think it's important to say that a lack of party democracy and a lack of debate around politics and policies is part of what led us here in the first place, so it would be a mistake for us not to use this opportunity to learn where we went wrong and to figure out where we go next."

Jo White, a Labour MP from the Red Wall who supports stricter immigration controls, disagreed that a contest is necessary given Burnham's widespread support.

Speaking on the same programme, she said,

"To be honest I think it [a contest] is going to be a pointless charade.
"The majority of MPs I've spoken to so far, even MPs I hadn't anticipated, are telling me they're going to be backing Andy."

White urged the party to focus on governance rather than internal competition, warning against prolonged infighting.

"If we have a competition or a contest, this whole thing will extend until September,"
"The Labour party loves turning in on itself, naval gazing I call it, and I've been very much scarred by the Corbyn years where we spent too long looking at ourselves rather than thinking about the country and doing what's best for the country."

Labour MP Nadia Whittome speaks in the House of Commons

Whittome is a young woman with bobbed, curly black hair and wears a leopard print shirt.
Image caption, Labour MP Nadia Whittome speaks in the House of Commons

Another Labour MP, Melanie Ward, has shifted her support from Streeting to Burnham, asserting that Burnham's policy agenda will be scrutinized regardless of whether other candidates emerge.

Ward, representing Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy, told Today,

"Whether or not there is a contest, and we don't know yet whether anyone will choose to stand against Andy, there will be a process,"
"We are waiting today for details of exactly how that process will look, how it will work. We know that there will be hustings.
"Andy will be setting out his programme for government, his ideas for things that he wants to do to bring the kind of change that our country needs."

When asked how hustings could occur without other candidates, Ward explained that Burnham would present his policies to Labour MPs for scrutiny.

Get the latest political analysis and big moments, delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

Thin, red banner promoting the Politics Essential newsletter with text saying, “Get the latest political analysis and big moments, delivered straight to your inbox every weekday”. There is also an image of the Houses of Parliament.

This article was sourced from bbc

Advertisement

Related News