Couple Prevails in Land Dispute Over Small Garden Patch
A couple has successfully won a legal dispute concerning a small strip of grass outside their home after their neighbour attempted to claim the land by placing a garden gnome on it.
Elizabeth Dobson and her partner Andrew Pleming had maintained the 2.4m-by-0.9m (8-by-3ft) patch of land located on Pointers Hill in Westcott, near Dorking, Surrey, for several years.
According to a London tribunal, the couple regularly mowed, raked, and cultivated the area with herbs and wildflowers.
However, when Alison and Darren Unsted moved into the neighbouring property in 2022, they asserted ownership of the patch, removed the existing plants, and placed a garden gnome on the land.
This action triggered a legal dispute centered on the principle of adverse possession, commonly referred to as 'squatters rights,' which permits an individual to claim ownership of land if they have used it as their own for a sufficient period.
Details of the Legal Proceedings
Dobson and Pleming contended that the disputed strip had long been regarded as part of their garden, a fact acknowledged by previous owners of both properties.
Evidence presented included a sign embedded in the soil displaying their house number, as reported by the Local Democracy Reporting Service.
Several former tenants of the neighbouring property also supported Dobson and Pleming's claim to the land.
The initial hearing took place at a First-tier Tribunal, which determined that the couple had clearly possessed the land only since approximately 2018, which did not meet the ten-year requirement for adverse possession.
However, upon appeal, the Upper Tribunal at the Royal Courts of Justice overturned this decision last week.
Judgment and Outcome
Judge Elizabeth Cooke, considering the care and attention the couple had devoted to the land, stated:
"It seems to me perfectly obvious that the appellants were in possession of the disputed land."
She further concluded that Dobson, Pleming, and their predecessors had maintained possession of the strip since at least 2002, well before the Unsteds took residence.
The judge ordered that the couple's application to register the land proceed as though the neighbours' objection had never been filed.
Additional Information
For further updates, follow BBC Surrey on Facebook and X. Story ideas can be sent to southeasttoday@bbc.co.uk or via WhatsApp at 08081 002250.
